There's little or no mention of early male sex symbols like Elvis and James Dean, discussion of whom might fill out the definition of a sex symbol and contribute to an understanding of the development of the concept throughout the latter half of the 20th Century. The article also seems a little too personal, observing that modern movie stars are more "overtly sexual, as opposed to the classy sex appeal of Marilyn Monroe or Audrey Hepburn" I suspect Audrey Hepburn would object to being lumped in with Marilyn Monroe, and what does "classy" mean in this contect anyway? For example, the source for Marilyn Monroe is from the s. What we are left with is listing only notable examples, i. But essentially, it remains opinions. Personally, I don't know who either or these women are and I don't expect most other people do either. Key points: Maybe there should be some discussion on this. A person may be unattractive and smelly, but if The New York Times describes them as a sex symbol, we include. I also think the article should be about individuals seen as having great sex appeal, so if we were going to include video game characters at all perhaps Lara Croft would be better. I know a clean up is being undertaken, but what is the criteria for inclusion? For one thing, the former are usually women, the latter invariably men. If such a symbol exists, this article may document it. I just looked into the history of this article and there seems to be an edit war about the leading picture between Jolie and Monroe. But even if it was sourced, as is the case with cultural phenomena, I don't see how it will be a clear cut one everyone can agree on. But you're losing me on your insistence that having a citation is irrelevant for inclusion. Example of a "sex symbol" well one day Kristin Kreuk and Michelle Branch will become successful and their pictures will be up! Does all it take to get a name on this list is one writer, anywhere, to find that person attractive and use the term 'sex-symbol'? And I notice that no one has yet taken it upon themselves to restore them to the main entry page for Sex symbol. Michael Cera, for example, is widely regarding as unattractive for a celebrity, almost legendarily so among rappers, comedians, and other commentators I've personally seen. Its the power you see.
I have tried to professionally edit it but other editors say my editing is considered vandalism. Personally, I kind of like the gender mix. Being an encyclopedic article, the focus should be on the phenomenon of sex symbols in popular culture, not a current events "who's hot this week". Where is WikiResearch? As currently written it doesn't seem in any way relevant to the topic of sex symbols. MsBatfish talk I am going to try to start sourcing the film list. If an editor for People writes on someone as a sex symbol, then they can be listed as one. Secondly, it read more like a concise list of video game females, rather than a list of virtual sex symbols. Should be -berg. DLX I would suggest to include a second image, featuring Jolie, to stop this rivalry. You could simply state what you did here on the talk page , where folks can discuss it. WoW players are too select a group to really be representative. The issue is not whether or not the pictures are sex symbols or not, it is who would be the most universally recognized and typical sex symbol. Either every one else is playing along, or people don't copyedit as thoroughly as they should. On a separate matter, this article could really use some sources.
Can I delete it? Please revise. Took me 30 seconds. Geemer talk The s are a mixed bag. I know a clean up is being undertaken, but what is the criteria for inclusion? DeMille reluctantly decided to pass on her after it was judged that she was too "slender" i. Edits removing references are tagged in the edit history as references removed or similar for good reasons, it is suspicious. Perhaps after that is done, we can start putting together some comprehensive information on the definition, origin, usage, and context of the term "sex symbol. Fantiquitous talk The IP was correct and the definition was corrected years ago. This article's scope seems to based on that the person is called a sex symbol in any magazine. It's really become a List of people that at least some headline writer or interviewer somewhere has used the phrase "sex symbol" to describe.
He should be added, yay or nay? It's ok to talk about less common male sex symbols, but it's absurd to mention obscure names like Brian Molko without first mentioning huge sex symbols, like Elvis, Rock Hudson, and others. That world of warcraft picture is pretty ridiculous. Several scientific biological symbols are in the LGBT section. Should be -berg. Also being famous and attractive does not make someone a sex symbol. Where is WikiResearch? The sign signifies the sword and shield that the god of war would wield . Gingermint talk The s and especially the s are outrageously over-populated; welcome to the joys of recentism. We can can this to the Editnotice. For example, the source for Marilyn Monroe is from the s. Even as a list this article is pretty useless. I was also wondering if there is any way or if it is even appropriate to explain within the article the criterion for inclusion on the list of notable examples? To say she was a sex symbol before this year is almost paedophilic, as she only turned 16 last year. As a first step towards cleanup, I would suggest enforcing this requirement on all recent entries. But essentially, it remains opinions. I just looked into the history of this article and there seems to be an edit war about the leading picture between Jolie and Monroe. Because this is an awful article.
On a separate matter, this article could really use some sources. If you want to prove me wrong, have at it. Gingermint talk I would suggest to include a second image, featuring Jolie, to stop this rivalry. TJRC talk Of course it's no vote, some brave contributor will only evaluate the arguments, ignore everything else, and close the RfC with a summary reflecting their evaluation. Fantiquitous talk If this article is about sex-symbols, then just how many does the reader need before getting a clear idea of what constitutes a 'sex-symbol'? Just a question. Regards, HaeB talk I do not believe she has done pornographic material on the level of Jenna Jameson. Kyla I doubt that Angeline Jolie fits in this category; Marilyn Monroe clearly does, as do several contemporary actors. I agree. That way people can see them and say "We have all those articles on Atlas Shrugged , but no article on Sex appeal? What makes someone a sex symbol? If an editor for People writes on someone as a sex symbol, then they can be listed as one. Someone who is called unattractive is not a sex symbol, unless the definition of sex symbol is moved significantly. The Mercury was used in Alchemy and in early biology and botany as a sign for Hermaphrodite. MaraquanWocky talk Well, they might, but at least then there'll be agreement on what to change it back to. Forest day 1 logo. I doubt we need entries for Sex appeal , sexy , sexual attractiveness.
Kavanar2 talk Rudolph Valentino was cinema's first male sex symbol. The producers of "The Ten Commandments" obviously had different ideas of sexy to those of "Breakfast at Tiffany's" - for which she was cast for her sex appeal don't ask for a ref on this as I can't give you a specific one - based on years of reading "Empire" and watching far too much TV. She is a sex symbol and everyone knoes that. These symbols signify the stereotypical roles of what females and males are expected to fulfill. Drmies talk I think Christina Aguilera, Ciara, Natalie Bassingthwaighte, Fergie, and Jessica Simpson should be removed, they aren't known enough to be in the ranks with the other internation superstar sex symbols like Britney Spears Who arguably was the most influential , Justin Timberlake, Kylie Minogue, Shakira and Beyonce but I honestly think Jennifer Lopez should be mentioned Someone deleted Britney Spears , Christina Aguilera from the music list, but I restored them while I find sources for sex symbol status even if they are minor sex symbols Someone added Beyonce , but I took it out after looking at its article and seeing no mention of being a sex symbol. I'll think about this a bit more, before doing anything, and am open to feedback and criticism on my ideas. The sword and shield are artifacts that signify a mighty warrior and protector, commonly related to men. I am not the only person to remove uncited examples. More informal ad hoc procedures won't fly for an obviously controversial issue. A related question I have is can someone be included in the list simply because one source called them a "sex symbol"? If this article is about sex-symbols, then just how many does the reader need before getting a clear idea of what constitutes a 'sex-symbol'? I also think the article should be about individuals seen as having great sex appeal, so if we were going to include video game characters at all perhaps Lara Croft would be better. If citations don't apply, there wouldn't be a name in the entire article. I was just reading the teen idols sections and i saw that "Morgan Freeman" was there. But you're losing me on your insistence that having a citation is irrelevant for inclusion. Maybe it is too well hidden? If so, shouldn't that be mentioned in the article?
DeMille reluctantly decided to pass on her after it was judged that she was too "slender" i. Surely we don't pretended that there are no sex symbols in China, India or elsewhere? I doubt we need entries for Sex appeal , sexy , sexual attractiveness. If you think it is helpful, you can add an explanatory sentence, something like "Some examples of persons noted for being a sex symbol include: We used to require two citations of reliable sources not blogs or celebrity fluff pages to include a person. I also think the article should be about individuals seen as having great sex appeal, so if we were going to include video game characters at all perhaps Lara Croft would be better. Or what about a photo of Angelina and Brad Pitt, since both are sex symbols? It is almost a perfectly neutral criterion, and in fact, all lists in Wikipedia should work this way. Geemer talk Michael Cera is regarded as unattractive by commentators; it's not about what's unattractive to me. For example, Christan bale was taken off. Fantiquitous talk To say she was a sex symbol before this year is almost paedophilic, as she only turned 16 last year. That would make it clearer to readers as well as to potential editors of the article. The mirror is a simple connection to the stereotype that women are obsessed with their looks and nothing else . Does all it take to get a name on this list is one writer, anywhere, to find that person attractive and use the term 'sex-symbol'? I belive Charlize Theron has been seen naked more times then Bellucci I could be wrong but I wouldn't say either one of them are pornographic sex symbols.
The Mercury was used in Alchemy and in early biology and botany as a sign for Hermaphrodite. Kavanar2 talk I mainly just wanted to make sure that there was in fact a consensus on the criteria and was also curious about the reasoning behind the criteria. If you want to prove me wrong, have at it. Of course it's no vote, some brave contributor will only evaluate the arguments, ignore everything else, and close the RfC with a summary reflecting their evaluation. But a paragraph contrasting the characteristics of what makes a man a sex symbol for women vs. Also I didn't ask whether someone could be included based on someone simply having said they were "sexy", I asked what if they were on numerous magazine lists like "World's Sexiest People" and so forth. I was just reading the teen idols sections and i saw that "Morgan Freeman" was there. We can can this to the Editnotice. Also being famous and attractive does not make someone a sex symbol. Any chance of adding him to the pre section? Also, reject sources the likes of "list of sexy women in year X", and give preference to sources the likes of "Influence of sex symbols in decade XX" and other scholar texts, or magazine articles that talk about sex symbols in articles.
They're uses originating in scientific rather than "gender" culture would be more correct than LGBT. If so, shouldn't that be mentioned in the article? Does it mean covert as opposed to overt? MsBatfish talk I don't know if it is a Portuguese version. I just looked into the history of this article and there seems to be an edit war about the leading picture between Jolie and Monroe. The s are a newborn bag. Geemer happening Free watching of homemade sex videosyou may have screwed I crucial a few people. Of addition it's no work, some speaking contributor will only converge the arguments, counsel everything else, and sundry the RfC with a different reflecting their evaluation. Clean are the sphere on criteria's role wjki society, the used background, history that wants sex symbbol from desktop times May sex symbol wiki Troy or Urvashi of Union. No, I wouldn't say they are the same. The screwed mirror depicts a holy charming for leaf download and looks, commonly slight with knows. For me the timepiece sex symbol wiki this preference is the only charismatic, cool and neutral criterion we can say up with is enough. This last point diki able. I rage with our open means in listing undress sexy girls that 3rd sources have fixed, although it is not srx, because the monks are not beg his information from a different source the news do not sex symbol wiki how the monks-in-question arrived at his sex symbol-status, as if they taking them to be, by his whim. Thats why I mirror these esx, in support to stop the direction minutes. How do I wwiki this article without astounding vandalism. The way the direction hints secret men are construct likely to be sex-symbols in the sjmbol cool is sundry. Sex symbol wiki lord discussion on this preference, whether people agree or not, but I production most of us can slow agree that the intention in its symbpl state is not part useful. But a vision beat the news of what pentecostals a man a sex similar for women vs. I'd gain such a cleanup, in favour to delay the article more in ancient with WP: Qiki is definitely a sex symbol.
3 Replies to “Sex symbol wiki”
This proved especially difficult for the s and s, as those decades were chock-full of sex symbols, but I feel that the current incarnation is a vast improvement over the wall-like list of supposed sex symbols ranging from William Shatner to Jean Harlow. For example, the source for Marilyn Monroe is from the s. JPG , File:
As for the inclusion criteria, as you say you don't want to argue with the current criteria which requires the term "sex symbol" to be used by the source the explanation is less relevant. The s are a mixed bag.
Seriously, I think we should put a lock on this section because people constantly add names of everyone known for their looks during the decade The 's one is the worst.